There isn't one best insulation for every attic. The right choice depends on the shape of the space, what's already there, whether there are rodent or moisture issues, and what you want to achieve. Here's how the common types compare in a typical Southern California home.
What are the main types of attic insulation?
Blown-in fiberglass
Loose fiberglass is blown across the attic floor with a machine. It fills around wiring, framing and obstacles, and it can be added on top of existing clean insulation. Fiberglass doesn't absorb much water and doesn't provide food for pests, though rodents can still nest in it. It's one of the most common choices for existing homes.
Blown-in cellulose
Cellulose is made mostly from recycled paper treated with fire retardants. It's denser than loose fiberglass, which helps it resist air movement through the insulation layer. It can settle more over time and doesn't handle getting wet as well, so roof leaks need to be fixed first.
Fiberglass or mineral wool batts
Batts come in pre-cut blankets sized to fit between joists. They work well in open attics with standard joist spacing and few obstacles. They're less effective when cut poorly or squeezed around wiring and pipes, because gaps and compression reduce performance. Mineral wool batts handle heat and moisture well and are more fire resistant than fiberglass.
Spray foam
Spray foam is applied as a liquid that expands and hardens. Open-cell and closed-cell foam both seal air leaks well. It's often used on the underside of the roof deck to create an unvented, conditioned attic, which can make sense when ducts and HVAC equipment are in the attic. It costs more, requires careful installation and makes future roof or wiring work harder.
Radiant barriers
A radiant barrier is a reflective foil layer installed under the roof deck or over the rafters. It reflects radiant heat from the roof and can help keep attics cooler in hot climates. It's not a substitute for insulation on the attic floor but can work alongside it, especially in inland homes with strong summer sun.
How do they compare?
| Type | Best for | Things to know |
|---|---|---|
| Blown-in fiberglass | Most existing attics, adding to old insulation | Fills gaps well, resists moisture |
| Blown-in cellulose | Existing attics, better air resistance | Can settle, keep it dry |
| Batts | Open attics with standard joist spacing | Must be cut and fit carefully |
| Spray foam | Unvented attics, sealing hard-to-reach gaps | Higher cost, professional install only |
| Radiant barrier | Hot inland attics, alongside insulation | Reflects heat, does not replace insulation |
Which is best for a typical San Diego attic?
Many homes in the area have low-pitched attics with ducts, a furnace and wiring running through them. Blown-in insulation fills around all of that without much cutting and fitting. In homes where the existing insulation is clean, new blown-in insulation can go right on top. If rodents or water have damaged the old insulation, it should be removed first.
Inland homes with hot afternoon sun may also benefit from a radiant barrier. Coastal homes with milder temperatures usually get the most value from proper depth and good air sealing.
Does air sealing matter as much as the insulation type?
Often more. Air leaks around light fixtures, wiring holes, plumbing vents, top plates and the attic hatch let air move freely between the house and attic. Fiberglass and cellulose don't stop that air movement on their own. Sealing those gaps before insulating makes any type perform better.
How do you choose?
- Look at what's in the attic now and whether it's clean and dry.
- Consider the layout: obstacles, joist spacing and headroom.
- Decide whether you want to keep a vented attic or create an unvented one.
- Factor in your budget and how long you plan to stay in the home.
- Get an inspection that includes air leaks, ventilation and ducts.
Our attic insulation team can inspect your attic and recommend a type and depth that fit your home. Estimates are free.




